Pills or a Procedure? Comparing Treatment Options for an Enlarged Prostate
From watchful waiting to medicines, minimally invasive procedures and surgery, here's how the main BPH treatments compare, and how to choose.
Alpha-blockers and 5-alpha reductase inhibitors help many men, but they can cause dizziness, ejaculation changes and other effects. Here's what to expect.
Medicine is the most common first treatment for bothersome urinary symptoms from an enlarged prostate. Most men tolerate it well. Still, every BPH medicine has possible side effects, and some of them affect sex and ejaculation. Knowing what to expect makes it easier to stay with a plan, or to speak up and switch if something is not working for you.
The AUA's 2026 guideline devotes an entire part to medical treatment of urinary symptoms from BPH.1 Here is an overview of the main medicine groups and their most common side effects.
Alpha-blockers include tamsulosin, alfuzosin, silodosin, doxazosin and terazosin. They relax smooth muscle in the prostate and at the bladder outlet so urine flows more easily. Many men notice a difference within days to a few weeks. They do not shrink the prostate.
Side effects to know about:
One important tip: if you need eye surgery, including cataract surgery, tell your doctors that you take, or have taken, an alpha-blocker. The tamsulosin drug information specifically advises telling your doctor before any eye surgery.2
Rarely, an erection that is painful and lasts for hours can occur. That needs emergency care.2
Finasteride and dutasteride block the body from turning testosterone into DHT, a hormone that drives prostate growth. Over several months, the prostate gets smaller. These medicines tend to help most when the prostate is enlarged. For BPH, it may take at least six months before symptoms improve.3
Possible side effects listed for finasteride include:3
Two more points matter. First, these medicines lower PSA, the blood test used in prostate cancer screening. Finasteride lowers PSA by about 50% within six months, so results need to be interpreted with that in mind.4 Second, the finasteride label notes that 5-alpha reductase inhibitors may increase the risk of high-grade prostate cancer.4 Neither point means you should avoid treatment. Both are good reasons to keep your PSA testing coordinated with the doctor who prescribes the medicine.
Many men with a larger prostate take an alpha-blocker and a 5-alpha reductase inhibitor together. In the MTOPS trial, the combination lowered the risk of BPH getting worse more than either medicine alone.5 The trade-off is the chance of side effects from both.
Other medicines may be added in specific situations:
If a medicine is causing problems, do not simply stop it on your own. Talk with your doctor first. There are often good alternatives:
Side effects are a valid reason to change your treatment. The best plan is one that relieves your symptoms and that you can live with.
Bring a full list of your medicines, including blood pressure pills and supplements, and mention any upcoming surgeries at your visit. That helps your urologist choose the safest option for you.
Call your doctor if a BPH medicine causes fainting, new depression or side effects you can't live with. Get emergency care for an erection that is painful and lasts for hours, or if you can't urinate.
This article is general education for adults and is not a substitute for personal medical advice. In an emergency, call 911.
From watchful waiting to medicines, minimally invasive procedures and surgery, here's how the main BPH treatments compare, and how to choose.
The PSA test is simple, but the decision isn't. Here's what the USPSTF and AUA/SUO guidelines say, and the questions that can help you choose.
Nighttime urination is common, but the cause isn't always an enlarged prostate. Evening fluids, leg swelling, diabetes and sleep apnea can all play a part.
Start with a private conversation with Dr. Gould at Greater Boston Urology in Milton.